UK ID Rant

Posted: May 17, 2011 in Fly-By-Night
Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Here is a think I hate about the UK: being carded at the supermarket for daring try and buy wine with my shopping. I hate it with the fiery vengeance of a thousand flaming suns. Not just because my only form of photo ID is my passport, which for obvious reasons I don’t carry with me at all times, and not just because I’m inevitably carded on the basis of what I’m wearing. Work clothes? Never carded. Velvet coat, gothy skirt, geeky t-shirt and/or hooded jacket? Hellooooo, humiliation!

Because that’s what I really hate about the whole experience, and the reason why I am currently furious: being carded is fucking humiliating. No, I do not care that it’s a “compliment” to be told I “look” under 25, because how I look shouldn’t matter, and in any case is such a ludicrously subjective measurement as to be rendered utterly useless – and that’s even before you get to the mind-boggling nannyism of stopping people based on a standard that requires them to look at least eight years older than the legal drinking age.

But look. I get that countries have stupid laws. I really do! And after the first few incidents, I started taking that into account. Either I take my passport shopping, or I choose my line at the checkout based on the age of the person serving (I have never been carded by anyone in their teens or twenties, and was once able to negotiate a purchase from a sympathetic employee in her thirties). If all else fails, I can now accept my circumstances with a graceful laugh and move on.

Or at least, I could. Until I went to Morrisons today, passport in hand, and was still refused service. Why, you ask? Because two weeks ago, Morrisons was apparently handed down a verdict from some trade commission or other – I rang their customer service line for details, and the woman on the other end didn’t seem to understand it either – specifying that, in order to keep their particular kind of licence, they could only accept a UK ID as proof of age. This is because, to paraphrase the bemused service rep, “it’s not possible for Morrisons staff to learn to accurately recognise the passports of the world.” I tried to ask her why this standard seemingly applied only to Morrisons, and not, for instance, to any other supermarket on the planet, but answers were not forthcoming. Thus, I made my complaint, hung up, and went to put away the bottle of wine I bought at Aldi  on the way home (the twentysomething employee didn’t card me), thinking vindictive thoughts about how at least, despite the inconvenience of having to visit two separate supermarkets, I’d managed to save £1.20.

There’s a special humiliation that accompanies being carded in the UK, in that it only ever seems to happen at supermarkets. You’re in there doing your weekly shop, you think of grabbing a bottle of wine – and all of a sudden, you’re overcome by a nagging, uneasy guilt, as though you’ve done something wrong. It’s like that momentary fear you get passing through the theft detectors on your way out of a shop: the everyday paranoia that worries they’re going to go off even though you haven’t stolen anything. Except in this case, it isn’t momentary. It poisons every trip to the shops I take, fearful of the inevitable humiliation. Perhaps if I were still a teenager, or if I was used to being carded, I wouldn’t care. But in the entire time I’ve lived in Australia and bought alcohol there – that is, from ages 17 through 24 – I have been asked for ID exactly once: outside a packed nightclub in the Rocks, on a Saturday night, when I was nineteen. That’s one carding in seven years.

Over here, it’s a different story. Including our visit in 2009, I’ve been in the UK for roughly ten months. In that time, I’ve been carded at least once in every single supermarket I’ve entered more than once. In the past week and a half alone, it’s happened twice. On one occasion when we were shopping together, my husband was carded because I was with him and he was the one paying, despite the fact that he is a fully grown man in his thirties. I cannot even begin to describe how angry this made me. Now, every time we shop together, I’m scared to be the one who pays, just in case the cashier decides to ask for ID. I am a married woman. I am twenty-five years old. I am not a student, though I reserve the right to dress like one without fear of having my age estimated downwards. STOP FUCKING CARDING ME.

And while you’re at it, stop carding my friends, too. A twenty-four-year-old friend was carded recently because she was buying a pair of scissors and was deemed to look under sixteen. (Scissors! WHAT THE FUCK!) Another friend, a PhD student in her late twenties, is repeatedly carded and refused service because her ID is international, even when she isn’t shopping at Morrisons. In fact, I’m starting to think that being female is a handicap all by itself, which is possibly unfair, but as one male friend pointed out, he at least can grow a beard to look older.

At the risk of upsetting the good half of the status quo, why am I never carded in pubs? Are pub servitors simply better at guessing my age? Are they more pragmatic than supermarket servers? Does the law apply differently on pub grounds? Or is it a combination of all three? What bothers me in this is the element of hypocritical absurdity: that right now, I could walk into any pub in the UK and buy a round of double tequila shots without anyone batting an eyelid while being simultaneously unable to purchase a single bottle of cider along with my groceries.

God only knows how I’ll cope if we ever visit America.

  1. Emily G says:

    Hello, bit of a lurker here. 🙂 Just wanted to say a big WORD to this post; there is some crazy inconsistent ID’ing here. The thing where they suspect an older person of buying your alcohol for you is really maddening. I understand that it’s basically a good thing for staff to be cautious, but … can’t there a certain amount of common sense involved?

    Also, re: your scissor story. A few years ago a friend of mine, age 21, bought a cheeseboard with, crucially, a cheeseknife and was ID’d because they thought she “might have been” under 16. What I want to know is what fifteen-yr-old is likely to be buying a cheeseknife anyway? 😉

    • fozmeadows says:

      It amazes me that there’s a law about IDing people who want to buy knives but look under sixteen. I mean, seriously: if you’re a troubled delinquent looking for something sharp, why not just buy a razor, or grab a steak knife from home? In what possible universe could asking for ID make a difference? And also, yes: a cheeseknife? Seriously? *boggles*

  2. Alex says:

    In Spain, I’m supposed to carry my passport with me at all times since I’m not Spanish and don’t have a citizenship card. And given how big and clunky the British passport it, that’s very irritating, but I could get seriously fined for being without ID. And no, my Spanish driver’s licence doesn’t count, although it does count for when I go shopping and want to use a credit card, fortunately.

    • fozmeadows says:

      My older half-brother lives in Barcelona, and a while ago he managed to let his passport expire while he was there. Very tricky to get a new one sorted out, as he had to find a certain number of friends who’d known him for more than two years – he managed it in the end, but just barely!

  3. mel says:

    Hi Foz – it’s me again. (One of your Goodreads friends) I am so glad you mentioned feeling slightly fearful walking between security scanners even though you know you haven’t stolen anything. I had wondered if it was just me. Once the scanners went off as I was leaving the grocery store and the clerk insisted on removing everything from the bags she had just finished packing. All the while she kept saying “Did you purchase any meat? There are chips in the meat packages.” I happen to be vegetarian and she never did find out why the alarm went off. I like to think that while she was going through the groceries (that she herself had packed) several real shoplifters had scampered out of the store with non-meat items. Ha!

    • fozmeadows says:

      How awkward! I understand why those scanners are there, but seriously, they always scare me. A friend of mine was actually taken aside by security guards once in David Jones because he set them off, just because he was in his late teens/early twenties at the time, and they thought he looked like a shoplifting delinquent. WTF?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s